I'm not aware the Clevenger Brothers reproduced that particular flask. I have an examle of that flask belived to be made in Eastern Europe which would fool a lot of people. The difference is the pontil has been polished off, a good indication of European work. Check the bottom.
The bottle in the images you provide is definitely a machine made reproduction.
I have a similar bottle. The aqua bottle pictured in the first post is old.
British glass makers were using older techniques very late, sometimes difficult to date British bottles by an applied lip, black glass or general crudity. I have a British black glass ale with an applied crown top lip. Something you'd never see on an American bottle.
Bottle diggers often find old bottles and jugs underneath the crawl space of old buildings. Sounds like the jars you found are 1920s to 1930s. But that doesn't mean there isn't older stuff. Some great finds have been made under old buildings,
Probably European 1870? I have a similar pontil clear bottle. Definitely not the kind of bottle which would be reproduced. If I were going to reproduce a bottle it wouldn't be a common perfume or medicine. Historical flask maybe, but not a common product bottle.
Soda and beer bottles were somewhat more expensive but quality wasn't an issue until after 1880. Even then quality was not always a high priority. It's amazing some bottles sold to bottlers had all sorts of imperfections yet were accepted and used anyway. As long as they didn't leak they were...
How about us being civil to each other and not get so trapped in defending ourselves we throw civility out the window. I too have entertained the same questions about Hutchinson bottles with somewhat extended necks. But after 50 years collecting chose to leave ithat and other questions open. I...
My Sullivan bottle illustrates well Hutchinson bottles with an elongated neck are nothing more than Hutchinson patent bottles. That bottle is a rarity for Sullivan, an anomaly. His common bottle is a 7 inch blob top. That bottle has the original spring stopper inside, no question it is a...
Onikowski, Trenton NJ - typical Hutchinson style pronounced shoulder, short neck, Daniel Sullivan, Hutchison with slightly elongated neck, Star Bottling Trenton soda with extended neck. Sullivan has original spring stopper , Star bottle often found with Putnam closure, never spring closure.